{
 "updated": "2026-10-07",
 "through": "2025-05",
 "pilot": {
  "start": "2023-09-24",
  "end": "2024-08-31",
  "routes": [
   "Bx18",
   "B60",
   "M116",
   "Q4",
   "S46/S96"
  ],
  "borough": {
   "Bx18": "Bronx",
   "B60": "Brooklyn",
   "M116": "Manhattan",
   "Q4": "Queens",
   "S46/S96": "Staten Island"
  }
 },
 "periods": {
  "Y0": "Oct 2021-Aug 2022",
  "Y1": "Oct 2022-Aug 2023",
  "Y2": "Oct 2023-Aug 2024",
  "Y3": "Oct 2024-May 2025"
 },
 "speed": {
  "pilot": {
   "effect": -1.4,
   "lo": -2.32,
   "hi": -0.29,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.6,
    "B60": -2.18,
    "M116": -1.16,
    "Q4": -2.7,
    "S46/S96": -1.52
   },
   "pilot_change": -2.53,
   "control_change": -1.14
  },
  "placebo": {
   "effect": 0.19,
   "lo": -1.75,
   "hi": 1.9,
   "per": {
    "B60": 1.0,
    "M116": -1.03,
    "Q4": -1.45,
    "S46/S96": 2.29
   },
   "pilot_change": 0.22,
   "control_change": 0.02
  },
  "after": {
   "effect": -0.14,
   "lo": -0.77,
   "hi": 0.47,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.19,
    "B60": -0.49,
    "M116": -0.51,
    "Q4": -0.41,
    "S46/S96": 0.53
   },
   "pilot_change": 0.07,
   "control_change": 0.21
  },
  "pilot_school": {
   "effect": -0.87,
   "lo": -1.48,
   "hi": -0.09,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.56,
    "B60": -1.18,
    "M116": -0.88,
    "Q4": -1.73,
    "S46/S96": -1.1
   },
   "pilot_change": -2.01,
   "control_change": -1.16
  },
  "pilot_summer": {
   "effect": -2.81,
   "lo": -4.65,
   "hi": -0.79,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.69,
    "B60": -4.83,
    "M116": -1.91,
    "Q4": -5.23,
    "S46/S96": -2.62
   },
   "pilot_change": -3.88,
   "control_change": -1.11
  },
  "pilot_peak": {
   "effect": -0.91,
   "lo": -2.2,
   "hi": 0.69,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 2.01,
    "B60": -2.27,
    "M116": -0.25,
    "Q4": -2.45,
    "S46/S96": -1.52
   },
   "pilot_change": -2.11,
   "control_change": -1.21
  },
  "after_vs_before": {
   "effect": -1.0,
   "lo": -1.92,
   "hi": -0.02,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.76,
    "B60": -1.66,
    "M116": -1.39,
    "Q4": -2.13,
    "S46/S96": -0.58
   },
   "pilot_change": -1.94,
   "control_change": -0.95
  },
  "pilot_all_controls": {
   "effect": -1.41,
   "lo": -2.18,
   "hi": -0.59
  },
  "fake_pilots": {
   "n": 2000,
   "p_two_sided": 0.003,
   "p5": -0.79,
   "p95": 0.74
  }
 },
 "slope": {
  "pilot": {
   "before": 7.51,
   "during": 7.32,
   "pct": -2.53,
   "before_oct_may": 7.47,
   "after": 7.33,
   "pct_after": -1.94
  },
  "comparison": {
   "before": 8.13,
   "during": 8.04,
   "pct": -1.14,
   "before_oct_may": 8.1,
   "after": 8.03,
   "pct_after": -0.95
  }
 },
 "series": [
  {
   "month": "2021-10",
   "gap": 1.06,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": 1.59,
    "M116": 3.55,
    "Q4": 1.32,
    "S46/S96": -2.14
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2021-11",
   "gap": 0.28,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": 0.43,
    "M116": 1.43,
    "Q4": 1.96,
    "S46/S96": -2.65
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2021-12",
   "gap": -0.08,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": 0.67,
    "M116": -0.09,
    "Q4": 1.73,
    "S46/S96": -2.59
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-01",
   "gap": -0.55,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -1.28,
    "M116": 1.9,
    "Q4": 0.69,
    "S46/S96": -3.43
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-02",
   "gap": 0.23,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -1.15,
    "M116": 2.5,
    "Q4": 2.99,
    "S46/S96": -3.28
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-03",
   "gap": -0.14,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -1.3,
    "M116": 1.57,
    "Q4": 2.21,
    "S46/S96": -2.95
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-04",
   "gap": 0.24,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -1.45,
    "M116": 3.39,
    "Q4": 2.02,
    "S46/S96": -2.89
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-05",
   "gap": 0.13,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -0.76,
    "M116": 3.32,
    "Q4": 1.65,
    "S46/S96": -3.58
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-06",
   "gap": -0.58,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -1.25,
    "M116": 0.52,
    "Q4": 1.35,
    "S46/S96": -2.89
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-07",
   "gap": -1.6,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -3.77,
    "M116": -3.23,
    "Q4": -0.19,
    "S46/S96": 0.87
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-08",
   "gap": -1.06,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": -2.5,
    "M116": -3.18,
    "Q4": 0.52,
    "S46/S96": 1.01
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-09",
   "gap": -0.17,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": null,
    "B60": 1.37,
    "M116": -0.7,
    "Q4": -0.35,
    "S46/S96": -1.0
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-10",
   "gap": -0.28,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.85,
    "B60": -0.06,
    "M116": 2.2,
    "Q4": -4.36,
    "S46/S96": -0.9
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-11",
   "gap": -0.55,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.36,
    "B60": 0.73,
    "M116": -1.18,
    "Q4": -0.08,
    "S46/S96": -1.83
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2022-12",
   "gap": -0.2,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.58,
    "B60": 0.72,
    "M116": -1.44,
    "Q4": 0.33,
    "S46/S96": -1.16
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-01",
   "gap": 0.33,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.13,
    "B60": 2.08,
    "M116": 0.59,
    "Q4": 0.26,
    "S46/S96": -1.37
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-02",
   "gap": 0.19,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.41,
    "B60": -0.5,
    "M116": 0.37,
    "Q4": 0.59,
    "S46/S96": 0.08
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-03",
   "gap": 0.13,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.76,
    "B60": 0.54,
    "M116": -0.47,
    "Q4": 0.36,
    "S46/S96": 1.0
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-04",
   "gap": -0.12,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.82,
    "B60": -1.41,
    "M116": 0.44,
    "Q4": 0.28,
    "S46/S96": 0.96
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-05",
   "gap": 0.18,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.9,
    "B60": -1.14,
    "M116": -0.12,
    "Q4": 0.57,
    "S46/S96": 0.73
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-06",
   "gap": 0.6,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.26,
    "B60": -0.07,
    "M116": 0.67,
    "Q4": 1.96,
    "S46/S96": 0.22
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-07",
   "gap": -0.29,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -1.46,
    "B60": -0.7,
    "M116": -0.78,
    "Q4": 0.43,
    "S46/S96": 1.1
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-08",
   "gap": -0.01,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.68,
    "B60": -0.14,
    "M116": -0.23,
    "Q4": -0.2,
    "S46/S96": 1.23
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-09",
   "gap": 0.72,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.48,
    "B60": 2.24,
    "M116": 1.52,
    "Q4": 0.19,
    "S46/S96": 0.16
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-10",
   "gap": -0.58,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.2,
    "B60": -0.12,
    "M116": -0.4,
    "Q4": -0.44,
    "S46/S96": -1.71
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-11",
   "gap": -0.52,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.82,
    "B60": -1.19,
    "M116": -0.97,
    "Q4": 0.05,
    "S46/S96": -1.3
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2023-12",
   "gap": -1.26,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -1.15,
    "B60": -1.11,
    "M116": -2.08,
    "Q4": -0.58,
    "S46/S96": -1.39
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-01",
   "gap": -1.31,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.58,
    "B60": 0.13,
    "M116": -2.78,
    "Q4": -0.14,
    "S46/S96": -3.14
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-02",
   "gap": -1.22,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.1,
    "B60": -0.91,
    "M116": -0.43,
    "Q4": -3.87,
    "S46/S96": -1.91
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-03",
   "gap": -0.97,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.54,
    "B60": -0.42,
    "M116": -2.08,
    "Q4": -2.7,
    "S46/S96": -1.14
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-04",
   "gap": -1.04,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.78,
    "B60": -2.97,
    "M116": 0.88,
    "Q4": -4.48,
    "S46/S96": -0.27
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-05",
   "gap": -0.33,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 3.19,
    "B60": -1.88,
    "M116": 1.28,
    "Q4": -3.69,
    "S46/S96": -0.43
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-06",
   "gap": -1.69,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.04,
    "B60": -2.97,
    "M116": -1.57,
    "Q4": -3.21,
    "S46/S96": -1.68
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-07",
   "gap": -3.13,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.28,
    "B60": -6.32,
    "M116": -1.8,
    "Q4": -5.17,
    "S46/S96": -1.93
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-08",
   "gap": -3.29,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -0.61,
    "B60": -6.01,
    "M116": -2.71,
    "Q4": -5.26,
    "S46/S96": -1.78
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-09",
   "gap": -0.36,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 2.54,
    "B60": -0.36,
    "M116": -0.53,
    "Q4": -3.49,
    "S46/S96": 0.11
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-10",
   "gap": -0.71,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 1.34,
    "B60": -0.16,
    "M116": -0.36,
    "Q4": -4.1,
    "S46/S96": -0.2
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-11",
   "gap": -0.51,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 2.13,
    "B60": -0.56,
    "M116": -1.04,
    "Q4": -3.33,
    "S46/S96": 0.32
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2024-12",
   "gap": -0.89,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.36,
    "B60": -0.07,
    "M116": -1.89,
    "Q4": -2.93,
    "S46/S96": 0.09
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2025-01",
   "gap": -1.53,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.6,
    "B60": -1.07,
    "M116": -1.48,
    "Q4": -3.28,
    "S46/S96": -2.36
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2025-02",
   "gap": -1.97,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": -2.59,
    "B60": -1.95,
    "M116": -0.59,
    "Q4": -2.65,
    "S46/S96": -2.05
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2025-03",
   "gap": -1.65,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 0.93,
    "B60": -2.09,
    "M116": -2.68,
    "Q4": -2.42,
    "S46/S96": -1.93
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2025-04",
   "gap": -0.97,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 3.19,
    "B60": -4.11,
    "M116": -1.39,
    "Q4": -1.33,
    "S46/S96": -1.06
   }
  },
  {
   "month": "2025-05",
   "gap": -0.09,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 2.12,
    "B60": -2.3,
    "M116": -1.29,
    "Q4": 0.96,
    "S46/S96": 0.09
   }
  }
 ],
 "units": {
  "Bx18": {
   "borough": "Bronx",
   "mph_y1": 6.06,
   "change_pct": -1.44,
   "comparison_change_pct": -2.03,
   "effect_pct": 0.6,
   "mph_y2": 5.97,
   "paid_y1": 1511,
   "comparison": [
    "BX4A",
    "BX33",
    "BX4",
    "BX17",
    "BX26"
   ],
   "comparison_mph_y1": [
    6.1,
    6.7,
    6.07,
    6.38,
    7.42
   ]
  },
  "B60": {
   "borough": "Brooklyn",
   "mph_y1": 6.58,
   "change_pct": -3.01,
   "comparison_change_pct": -0.85,
   "effect_pct": -2.18,
   "mph_y2": 6.38,
   "paid_y1": 4783,
   "comparison": [
    "B70",
    "B47",
    "B16",
    "B67",
    "B69"
   ],
   "comparison_mph_y1": [
    6.52,
    6.72,
    6.81,
    6.63,
    6.55
   ]
  },
  "M116": {
   "borough": "Manhattan",
   "mph_y1": 5.69,
   "change_pct": -2.03,
   "comparison_change_pct": -0.88,
   "effect_pct": -1.16,
   "mph_y2": 5.57,
   "paid_y1": 5992,
   "comparison": [
    "M100",
    "M96",
    "M106"
   ],
   "comparison_mph_y1": [
    6.12,
    5.27,
    5.48
   ]
  },
  "Q4": {
   "borough": "Queens",
   "mph_y1": 8.25,
   "change_pct": -4.49,
   "comparison_change_pct": -1.84,
   "effect_pct": -2.7,
   "mph_y2": 7.88,
   "paid_y1": 6553,
   "comparison": [
    "Q38",
    "Q64",
    "Q37",
    "Q13",
    "Q12"
   ],
   "comparison_mph_y1": [
    8.02,
    8.47,
    8.64,
    8.69,
    8.7
   ]
  },
  "S46/S96": {
   "borough": "Staten Island",
   "mph_y1": 10.95,
   "change_pct": -1.62,
   "comparison_change_pct": -0.11,
   "effect_pct": -1.52,
   "mph_y2": 10.77,
   "paid_y1": 3035,
   "comparison": [
    "S59",
    "S74",
    "S78",
    "S93",
    "S56"
   ],
   "comparison_mph_y1": [
    13.06,
    13.08,
    13.32,
    13.51,
    13.81
   ]
  }
 },
 "riders": {
  "pilot_routes_paid_per_weekday": {
   "Y1": {
    "Bx18": 1511,
    "B60": 4783,
    "M116": 5992,
    "Q4": 6553,
    "S46/S96": 3035
   },
   "Y2": {
    "Bx18": 11,
    "B60": 22,
    "M116": 57,
    "Q4": 43,
    "S46/S96": 67
   },
   "Y3": {
    "Bx18": 1826,
    "B60": 4931,
    "M116": 6163,
    "Q4": 6376,
    "S46/S96": 3349
   }
  },
  "pilot_routes_after_vs_before": {
   "effect": 0.25,
   "lo": -9.68,
   "hi": 13.11,
   "per": {
    "Bx18": 25.84,
    "B60": -3.01,
    "M116": -8.59,
    "Q4": -13.66,
    "S46/S96": 5.13
   }
  },
  "nearby": {
   "pilot": {
    "effect": -4.8,
    "lo": -8.7,
    "hi": -0.44,
    "routes": 19,
    "paid_riders_per_weekday": -3086,
    "paid_riders_lo": -6419,
    "paid_riders_hi": -135
   },
   "placebo": {
    "effect": 0.51,
    "lo": -6.59,
    "hi": 9.33,
    "routes": 19,
    "paid_riders_per_weekday": 936,
    "paid_riders_lo": -4191,
    "paid_riders_hi": 7829
   },
   "after": {
    "effect": 0.86,
    "lo": -2.68,
    "hi": 4.8,
    "routes": 19,
    "paid_riders_per_weekday": 717,
    "paid_riders_lo": -1615,
    "paid_riders_hi": 3591
   },
   "after_vs_before": {
    "effect": -3.22,
    "lo": -8.96,
    "hi": 3.55,
    "routes": 19,
    "paid_riders_per_weekday": -1808,
    "paid_riders_lo": -6177,
    "paid_riders_hi": 2669
   }
  },
  "nearby_routes": [
   {
    "route": "Q5",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.41,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 8885,
    "pilot_pct": -13.23,
    "comparison": [
     "Q12",
     "Q28",
     "Q64",
     "Q37",
     "Q13"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -0.09,
    "mph_y1": 8.81
   },
   {
    "route": "Q85",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.34,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 7768,
    "pilot_pct": -12.12,
    "comparison": [
     "Q28",
     "Q12",
     "Q13",
     "Q37",
     "Q64"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.14,
    "mph_y1": 9.55
   },
   {
    "route": "Q83",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.33,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 6483,
    "pilot_pct": -5.63,
    "comparison": [
     "Q37",
     "Q13",
     "Q64",
     "Q12",
     "Q38"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.88,
    "mph_y1": 8.58
   },
   {
    "route": "BX3",
    "borough": "Bronx",
    "near": "Bx18",
    "share_within_400m": 0.21,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 6367,
    "pilot_pct": 0.92,
    "comparison": [
     "BX39",
     "BX21",
     "BX28",
     "BX7",
     "BX6"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.77,
    "mph_y1": 7.21
   },
   {
    "route": "BX11",
    "borough": "Bronx",
    "near": "Bx18",
    "share_within_400m": 0.25,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 6107,
    "pilot_pct": 3.36,
    "comparison": [
     "BX22",
     "BX15",
     "BX21",
     "BX39",
     "BX19"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 1.2,
    "mph_y1": 5.91
   },
   {
    "route": "BX35",
    "borough": "Bronx",
    "near": "Bx18",
    "share_within_400m": 0.27,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 6078,
    "pilot_pct": -0.74,
    "comparison": [
     "BX19",
     "BX22",
     "BX15",
     "BX21",
     "BX39"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.94,
    "mph_y1": 5.47
   },
   {
    "route": "BX13",
    "borough": "Bronx",
    "near": "Bx18",
    "share_within_400m": 0.24,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 5690,
    "pilot_pct": 0.72,
    "comparison": [
     "BX22",
     "BX15",
     "BX21",
     "BX39",
     "BX6"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 2.12,
    "mph_y1": 6.33
   },
   {
    "route": "Q77",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.23,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 4214,
    "pilot_pct": -8.14,
    "comparison": [
     "Q39",
     "Q110",
     "Q40",
     "Q1",
     "Q55"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 1.11,
    "mph_y1": 8.19
   },
   {
    "route": "Q84",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.44,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 3345,
    "pilot_pct": -3.3,
    "comparison": [
     "Q11",
     "Q16",
     "Q22",
     "Q100",
     "Q76"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -1.05,
    "mph_y1": 10.41
   },
   {
    "route": "S44",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.21,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 2828,
    "pilot_pct": 0.48,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -0.6,
    "mph_y1": 10.88
   },
   {
    "route": "BX32",
    "borough": "Bronx",
    "near": "Bx18",
    "share_within_400m": 0.25,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 2573,
    "pilot_pct": 7.77,
    "comparison": [
     "BX4",
     "BX4A",
     "BX17",
     "BX15",
     "BX38"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.59,
    "mph_y1": 5.73
   },
   {
    "route": "S48",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.3,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 2528,
    "pilot_pct": -11.49,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -0.91,
    "mph_y1": 9.57
   },
   {
    "route": "B42",
    "borough": "Brooklyn",
    "near": "B60",
    "share_within_400m": 0.22,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 1434,
    "pilot_pct": -20.2,
    "comparison": [
     "B37",
     "B74",
     "B2",
     "B7",
     "B65"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 1.23,
    "mph_y1": 7.39
   },
   {
    "route": "Q42",
    "borough": "Queens",
    "near": "Q4",
    "share_within_400m": 0.74,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 873,
    "pilot_pct": -8.94,
    "comparison": [
     "Q26",
     "Q48",
     "Q67",
     "Q15",
     "Q15A"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -1.89,
    "mph_y1": 8.93
   },
   {
    "route": "S66",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.26,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 831,
    "pilot_pct": -2.29,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -0.04,
    "mph_y1": 11.63
   },
   {
    "route": "S98",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.31,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 730,
    "pilot_pct": -3.91,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -1.6,
    "mph_y1": 10.89
   },
   {
    "route": "S94",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.24,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 484,
    "pilot_pct": 12.14,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -0.8,
    "mph_y1": 11.72
   },
   {
    "route": "S42",
    "borough": "Staten Island",
    "near": "S46/S96",
    "share_within_400m": 0.54,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 389,
    "pilot_pct": 10.35,
    "comparison": [
     "S59",
     "S74",
     "S78",
     "S93",
     "S56"
    ],
    "speed_pct": -3.3,
    "mph_y1": 11.42
   },
   {
    "route": "M35",
    "borough": "Manhattan",
    "near": "M116",
    "share_within_400m": 0.27,
    "paid_per_weekday_y1": 148,
    "pilot_pct": -12.07,
    "comparison": [
     "M100",
     "M106",
     "M96"
    ],
    "speed_pct": 0.03,
    "mph_y1": 12.13
   }
  ],
  "nearby_series": [
   {
    "month": "2021-10",
    "gap": 1.37
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-11",
    "gap": 0.45
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-12",
    "gap": -0.56
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-01",
    "gap": 1.99
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-02",
    "gap": 0.5
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-03",
    "gap": 1.49
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-04",
    "gap": -1.1
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-05",
    "gap": -1.73
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-06",
    "gap": -1.58
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-07",
    "gap": -3.8
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-08",
    "gap": -2.45
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-09",
    "gap": -1.17
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-10",
    "gap": 4.71
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-11",
    "gap": 2.68
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-12",
    "gap": 2.71
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-01",
    "gap": 1.96
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-02",
    "gap": 0.97
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-03",
    "gap": 0.0
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-04",
    "gap": -2.15
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-05",
    "gap": -1.04
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-06",
    "gap": -2.35
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-07",
    "gap": -3.34
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-08",
    "gap": -3.76
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-09",
    "gap": -0.54
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-10",
    "gap": -0.85
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-11",
    "gap": 2.65
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-12",
    "gap": -3.01
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-01",
    "gap": -4.29
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-02",
    "gap": -4.67
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-03",
    "gap": -4.02
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-04",
    "gap": -2.48
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-05",
    "gap": -6.1
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-06",
    "gap": -8.05
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-07",
    "gap": -10.14
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-08",
    "gap": -11.02
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-09",
    "gap": -3.59
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-10",
    "gap": -1.73
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-11",
    "gap": -0.56
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-12",
    "gap": -0.91
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-01",
    "gap": -2.28
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-02",
    "gap": -1.6
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-03",
    "gap": -3.36
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-04",
    "gap": -2.47
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-05",
    "gap": -3.43
   }
  ],
  "pilot_paid_series": [
   {
    "month": "2021-10",
    "paid": 23837
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-11",
    "paid": 22138
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-12",
    "paid": 19917
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-01",
    "paid": 18961
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-02",
    "paid": 21026
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-03",
    "paid": 23816
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-04",
    "paid": 22090
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-05",
    "paid": 22779
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-06",
    "paid": 22396
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-07",
    "paid": 20918
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-08",
    "paid": 20891
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-09",
    "paid": 23053
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-10",
    "paid": 24092
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-11",
    "paid": 22346
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-12",
    "paid": 20889
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-01",
    "paid": 21379
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-02",
    "paid": 22015
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-03",
    "paid": 23798
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-04",
    "paid": 22260
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-05",
    "paid": 22959
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-06",
    "paid": 21243
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-07",
    "paid": 19984
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-08",
    "paid": 19645
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-09",
    "paid": 15993
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-10",
    "paid": 98
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-11",
    "paid": 130
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-12",
    "paid": 146
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-01",
    "paid": 172
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-02",
    "paid": 168
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-03",
    "paid": 219
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-04",
    "paid": 457
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-05",
    "paid": 239
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-06",
    "paid": 179
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-07",
    "paid": 205
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-08",
    "paid": 193
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-09",
    "paid": 22737
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-10",
    "paid": 24199
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-11",
    "paid": 22281
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-12",
    "paid": 20762
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-01",
    "paid": 21107
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-02",
    "paid": 22762
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-03",
    "paid": 24141
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-04",
    "paid": 23396
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-05",
    "paid": 22516
   }
  ],
  "mta_weekday_gain_school": 13434,
  "nearby_speed": {
   "pilot": {
    "effect": 0.47,
    "lo": -0.01,
    "hi": 0.92,
    "routes": 19,
    "nearby_change": -1.02,
    "comparison_change": -1.48
   },
   "placebo": {
    "effect": -0.11,
    "lo": -0.72,
    "hi": 0.56,
    "routes": 19,
    "nearby_change": 0.09,
    "comparison_change": 0.2
   },
   "after": {
    "effect": -0.42,
    "lo": -1.19,
    "hi": 0.34,
    "routes": 19,
    "nearby_change": -0.77,
    "comparison_change": -0.36
   },
   "pilot_school": {
    "effect": 0.85,
    "lo": 0.31,
    "hi": 1.38,
    "routes": 19,
    "nearby_change": -0.72,
    "comparison_change": -1.55
   },
   "pilot_summer": {
    "effect": -0.54,
    "lo": -1.35,
    "hi": 0.16,
    "routes": 19,
    "nearby_change": -1.83,
    "comparison_change": -1.3
   },
   "corr_riders_speed": -0.2
  },
  "nearby_speed_series": [
   {
    "month": "2021-10",
    "gap": 0.01
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-11",
    "gap": 0.45
   },
   {
    "month": "2021-12",
    "gap": 0.32
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-01",
    "gap": 0.04
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-02",
    "gap": 0.13
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-03",
    "gap": 0.36
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-04",
    "gap": 0.26
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-05",
    "gap": 0.15
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-06",
    "gap": -0.02
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-07",
    "gap": -0.39
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-08",
    "gap": -0.07
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-09",
    "gap": -0.23
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-10",
    "gap": -0.66
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-11",
    "gap": 0.21
   },
   {
    "month": "2022-12",
    "gap": 0.38
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-01",
    "gap": 0.07
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-02",
    "gap": 0.03
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-03",
    "gap": -0.39
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-04",
    "gap": -0.52
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-05",
    "gap": 0.15
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-06",
    "gap": 0.25
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-07",
    "gap": 0.2
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-08",
    "gap": 0.28
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-09",
    "gap": 1.08
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-10",
    "gap": 1.38
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-11",
    "gap": 1.66
   },
   {
    "month": "2023-12",
    "gap": 1.13
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-01",
    "gap": 1.06
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-02",
    "gap": 0.13
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-03",
    "gap": 0.41
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-04",
    "gap": -0.09
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-05",
    "gap": 0.36
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-06",
    "gap": -0.53
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-07",
    "gap": -0.17
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-08",
    "gap": -0.19
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-09",
    "gap": 0.27
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-10",
    "gap": -0.38
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-11",
    "gap": 0.23
   },
   {
    "month": "2024-12",
    "gap": 0.21
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-01",
    "gap": 0.25
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-02",
    "gap": 0.18
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-03",
    "gap": 1.0
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-04",
    "gap": 0.8
   },
   {
    "month": "2025-05",
    "gap": 0.38
   }
  ]
 },
 "cost": {
  "days": {
   "school_weekdays": 180,
   "school_weekend_days": 71,
   "summer_weekdays": 65,
   "summer_weekend_days": 27
  },
  "extra_daily": {
   "school_weekday": 13434,
   "summer_weekday": 14560,
   "school_weekend": 7642,
   "summer_weekend": 9031
  },
  "extra_trips": 4150939,
  "total_cost_usd": 16475000,
  "farebox_loss_usd": 10880000,
  "per_extra_trip_usd": 3.97,
  "farebox_per_extra_trip_usd": 2.62
 },
 "mta": {
  "riders": {
   "B60": {
    "school_pre": 10081,
    "school_gain": 3464,
    "summer_pre": 9257,
    "summer_gain": 4154
   },
   "Bx18": {
    "school_pre": 4703,
    "school_gain": 1369,
    "summer_pre": 4548,
    "summer_gain": 1444
   },
   "M116": {
    "school_pre": 10424,
    "school_gain": 3011,
    "summer_pre": 9557,
    "summer_gain": 3570
   },
   "Q4": {
    "school_pre": 10762,
    "school_gain": 3744,
    "summer_pre": 8528,
    "summer_gain": 3900
   },
   "S46/S96": {
    "school_pre": 8228,
    "school_gain": 1846,
    "summer_pre": 5876,
    "summer_gain": 1492
   }
  },
  "speed_peak": {
   "B60": {
    "school_pre": 6.0,
    "school_pilot": 5.9,
    "school_pct": -2.2,
    "summer_pre": 6.1,
    "summer_pilot": 5.8,
    "summer_pct": -4.9
   },
   "Bx18": {
    "school_pre": 5.6,
    "school_pilot": 5.6,
    "school_pct": 0.5,
    "summer_pre": 5.6,
    "summer_pilot": 5.6,
    "summer_pct": 0.0
   },
   "M116": {
    "school_pre": 5.3,
    "school_pilot": 5.2,
    "school_pct": -2.6,
    "summer_pre": 5.4,
    "summer_pilot": 5.3,
    "summer_pct": -1.9
   },
   "Q4": {
    "school_pre": 7.8,
    "school_pilot": 7.4,
    "school_pct": -4.8,
    "summer_pre": 7.5,
    "summer_pilot": 7.0,
    "summer_pct": -6.7
   },
   "S46/S96": {
    "school_pre": 10.3,
    "school_pilot": 10.0,
    "school_pct": -2.2,
    "summer_pre": 10.3,
    "summer_pilot": 10.0,
    "summer_pct": -2.9
   }
  },
  "system": {
   "riders_school_pct": 6,
   "riders_summer_pct": 9,
   "speed_school_pct": -2.3,
   "speed_summer_pct": -1.5,
   "pilot_riders_school_pct": 30,
   "pilot_riders_summer_pct": 40,
   "pilot_speed_school_pct": -2.2,
   "pilot_speed_summer_pct": -4.3
  },
  "survey": {
   "n_pilot": 3600,
   "n_pre": 2200,
   "new_to_route_pct": 12,
   "rode_4plus_days_new_pct": 40,
   "rode_4plus_days_existing_pct": 69,
   "new_riders_before": {
    "other MTA bus or subway": 27,
    "didn't make the trip": 23,
    "walked": 22,
    "other": 17,
    "drove or taxi": 11
   },
   "income_under_28k_new_pct": 44,
   "income_under_28k_existing_pct": 46,
   "income_under_50k_new_pct": 70,
   "income_under_50k_existing_pct": 73
  },
  "weekend": {
   "B60": {
    "school_pre": 4794,
    "school_gain": 1833,
    "summer_gain": 2407
   },
   "Bx18": {
    "school_pre": 2072,
    "school_gain": 788,
    "summer_gain": 940
   },
   "M116": {
    "school_pre": 5412,
    "school_gain": 1860,
    "summer_gain": 1802
   },
   "Q4": {
    "school_pre": 4371,
    "school_gain": 2007,
    "summer_gain": 2706
   },
   "S46/S96": {
    "school_pre": 3586,
    "school_gain": 1154,
    "summer_gain": 1176
   }
  },
  "weekend_pct": {
   "school": 38,
   "summer": 40,
   "system_school": 8,
   "system_summer": 10
  },
  "cost": {
   "total": 16475000,
   "farebox": 10880000,
   "nearby": 1722000,
   "aar": 2788000,
   "upfront": 1085000,
   "by_route": {
    "B60": 4787000,
    "Bx18": 1269000,
    "M116": 3914000,
    "Q4": 3865000,
    "S46/S96": 2641000
   },
   "aar_by_route": {
    "B60": 1180000,
    "Bx18": 182000,
    "M116": 496000,
    "Q4": 388000,
    "S46/S96": 542000
   }
  },
  "cap_usd": 15000000,
  "service_delivered_pp": {
   "pilot": -1.6,
   "system": 0.2
  },
  "journey_time_pp": {
   "pilot": -2.2,
   "system": -1.6
  },
  "dwell_pct": {
   "pilot": 7.0,
   "system": 1.0,
   "pilot_summer": 8.2,
   "system_summer": 0.7
  },
  "evasion_nearby_pp": {
   "nearby": 8.1,
   "system": 7.2,
   "nearby_pre": 47.0,
   "nearby_pilot": 55.1
  },
  "assaults": {
   "pilot_pre": 47,
   "pilot": 32,
   "pilot_pct": -31.9,
   "system_pre": 1663,
   "system": 1407,
   "system_pct": -15.4
  },
  "assaults_by_route": {
   "B60": [
    14,
    10
   ],
   "Bx18": [
    7,
    2
   ],
   "M116": [
    10,
    6
   ],
   "Q4": [
    5,
    9
   ],
   "S46/S96": [
    11,
    5
   ]
  },
  "source": "https://www.mta.info/document/177466"
 }
}