{"updated":"2026-10-05","scheduleDate":"2026-09-16","costs":{"calibrated":11,"low":4,"mta":20,"regression":31,"regressionCi":[23.7,37.4],"regressionExact":30.8},"walkWeight":2,"quietUse":0.5,"scenarios":[{"rule":750,"stops":17333,"removed":2665,"pctRemoved":15.4,"routes":218,"spacingBefore":1303,"spacingAfter":1449,"riderHoursPerSecond":510.83,"walkHours1x":5168.6,"minPerTripPerSecond":0.0823,"busHoursPerSecond":71.22,"walkMinEach":1.1,"calibrated":{"minPerTrip":0.9,"riderHoursSaved":5619,"walkHours2x":10337,"net":-4718,"netQuiet":450,"busHoursSaved":783}},{"rule":1000,"stops":17333,"removed":5089,"pctRemoved":29.4,"routes":248,"spacingBefore":1303,"spacingAfter":1672,"riderHoursPerSecond":980.43,"walkHours1x":13132.4,"minPerTripPerSecond":0.1584,"busHoursPerSecond":137.24,"walkMinEach":1.39,"calibrated":{"minPerTrip":1.74,"riderHoursSaved":10785,"walkHours2x":26265,"net":-15480,"netQuiet":-2348,"busHoursSaved":1510}},{"rule":1320,"stops":17333,"removed":7346,"pctRemoved":42.4,"routes":255,"spacingBefore":1303,"spacingAfter":2008,"riderHoursPerSecond":1422.13,"walkHours1x":25696.5,"minPerTripPerSecond":0.23,"busHoursPerSecond":199.09,"walkMinEach":1.79,"calibrated":{"minPerTrip":2.53,"riderHoursSaved":15643,"walkHours2x":51393,"net":-35750,"netQuiet":-10053,"busHoursSaved":2190}}],"target":{"summary":{"rule":750,"routes":40,"removed":1064,"stops":3726,"riders":187500.0,"riderHoursSaved":2428,"walkHours2x":3671,"netQuiet":593,"net":-1243,"busHoursSaved":319,"allRoutes":218,"allNetQuiet":450,"allNet":-4718,"routesPositiveAtAverageUse":1,"boroughs":{"Brooklyn":25,"Manhattan":13,"Staten Island":2},"routesPositive":{"750":{"low":0,"calibrated":1,"mta":63,"regression":177},"1000":{"low":0,"calibrated":1,"mta":8,"regression":133},"1320":{"low":0,"calibrated":1,"mta":1,"regression":55}}},"minBreakevenUse":0.6,"minRemoved":5,"routes":[{"route":"M4","borough":"Manhattan","stops":152,"removed":47,"spacingBefore":691,"spacingAfter":1008,"riders":11020.0,"minPerTrip":4.3,"riderHoursSaved":161.2,"walkHours2x":239.6,"net":-78.4,"netQuiet":41.4,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.4,"busHoursSaved":18.8},{"route":"B3","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":87,"removed":33,"spacingBefore":662,"spacingAfter":1082,"riders":7050.0,"minPerTrip":3.0,"riderHoursSaved":133.6,"walkHours2x":192.1,"net":-58.6,"netQuiet":37.5,"breakevenUse":0.7,"breakevenCost":15.8,"busHoursSaved":13.1},{"route":"M11","borough":"Manhattan","stops":116,"removed":36,"spacingBefore":699,"spacingAfter":1021,"riders":8290.0,"minPerTrip":3.3,"riderHoursSaved":120.8,"walkHours2x":181.8,"net":-61.0,"netQuiet":29.9,"breakevenUse":0.66,"breakevenCost":16.6,"busHoursSaved":10.0},{"route":"M1","borough":"Manhattan","stops":133,"removed":38,"spacingBefore":684,"spacingAfter":964,"riders":7950.0,"minPerTrip":3.5,"riderHoursSaved":108.8,"walkHours2x":161.8,"net":-53.0,"netQuiet":27.9,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.4,"busHoursSaved":12.2},{"route":"B1","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":98,"removed":23,"spacingBefore":743,"spacingAfter":979,"riders":10790.0,"minPerTrip":2.1,"riderHoursSaved":112.4,"walkHours2x":171.4,"net":-59.1,"netQuiet":26.7,"breakevenUse":0.66,"breakevenCost":16.8,"busHoursSaved":9.1},{"route":"B8","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":151,"removed":43,"spacingBefore":709,"spacingAfter":996,"riders":9040.0,"minPerTrip":3.9,"riderHoursSaved":118.9,"walkHours2x":184.9,"net":-66.0,"netQuiet":26.5,"breakevenUse":0.64,"breakevenCost":17.1,"busHoursSaved":14.5},{"route":"B36","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":81,"removed":23,"spacingBefore":706,"spacingAfter":995,"riders":6880.0,"minPerTrip":2.1,"riderHoursSaved":90.8,"walkHours2x":134.4,"net":-43.6,"netQuiet":23.6,"breakevenUse":0.68,"breakevenCost":16.3,"busHoursSaved":9.4},{"route":"B60","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":133,"removed":46,"spacingBefore":638,"spacingAfter":983,"riders":3840.0,"minPerTrip":4.2,"riderHoursSaved":68.3,"walkHours2x":90.7,"net":-22.4,"netQuiet":22.9,"breakevenUse":0.75,"breakevenCost":14.6,"busHoursSaved":12.8},{"route":"M3","borough":"Manhattan","stops":162,"removed":44,"spacingBefore":704,"spacingAfter":972,"riders":8520.0,"minPerTrip":4.0,"riderHoursSaved":107.1,"walkHours2x":169.9,"net":-62.8,"netQuiet":22.1,"breakevenUse":0.63,"breakevenCost":17.5,"busHoursSaved":12.9},{"route":"B15","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":138,"removed":52,"spacingBefore":749,"spacingAfter":1213,"riders":5710.0,"minPerTrip":4.8,"riderHoursSaved":94.1,"walkHours2x":151.2,"net":-57.1,"netQuiet":18.5,"breakevenUse":0.62,"breakevenCost":17.7,"busHoursSaved":23.3},{"route":"M7","borough":"Manhattan","stops":117,"removed":28,"spacingBefore":712,"spacingAfter":939,"riders":7310.0,"minPerTrip":2.6,"riderHoursSaved":80.5,"walkHours2x":125.1,"net":-44.5,"netQuiet":18.0,"breakevenUse":0.64,"breakevenCost":17.1,"busHoursSaved":8.1},{"route":"B44","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":128,"removed":32,"spacingBefore":726,"spacingAfter":971,"riders":7030.0,"minPerTrip":2.9,"riderHoursSaved":78.5,"walkHours2x":121.1,"net":-42.6,"netQuiet":17.9,"breakevenUse":0.65,"breakevenCost":17.0,"busHoursSaved":12.7},{"route":"M10","borough":"Manhattan","stops":88,"removed":34,"spacingBefore":637,"spacingAfter":1054,"riders":2940.0,"minPerTrip":3.1,"riderHoursSaved":58.9,"walkHours2x":82.6,"net":-23.7,"netQuiet":17.6,"breakevenUse":0.71,"breakevenCost":15.4,"busHoursSaved":8.2},{"route":"B49","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":131,"removed":34,"spacingBefore":717,"spacingAfter":974,"riders":5650.0,"minPerTrip":3.1,"riderHoursSaved":67.5,"walkHours2x":99.9,"net":-32.4,"netQuiet":17.5,"breakevenUse":0.68,"breakevenCost":16.3,"busHoursSaved":12.4},{"route":"M102","borough":"Manhattan","stops":113,"removed":25,"spacingBefore":734,"spacingAfter":949,"riders":7540.0,"minPerTrip":2.3,"riderHoursSaved":74.1,"walkHours2x":116.1,"net":-42.1,"netQuiet":16.0,"breakevenUse":0.64,"breakevenCost":17.2,"busHoursSaved":8.4},{"route":"B47","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":113,"removed":34,"spacingBefore":694,"spacingAfter":998,"riders":3980.0,"minPerTrip":3.1,"riderHoursSaved":56.9,"walkHours2x":81.7,"net":-24.9,"netQuiet":16.0,"breakevenUse":0.7,"breakevenCost":15.8,"busHoursSaved":10.4},{"route":"B43","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":103,"removed":25,"spacingBefore":708,"spacingAfter":941,"riders":4860.0,"minPerTrip":2.3,"riderHoursSaved":54.7,"walkHours2x":78.9,"net":-24.2,"netQuiet":15.2,"breakevenUse":0.69,"breakevenCost":15.9,"busHoursSaved":7.1},{"route":"B63","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":109,"removed":28,"spacingBefore":744,"spacingAfter":1008,"riders":6930.0,"minPerTrip":2.6,"riderHoursSaved":78.6,"walkHours2x":127.8,"net":-49.2,"netQuiet":14.7,"breakevenUse":0.61,"breakevenCost":17.9,"busHoursSaved":7.8},{"route":"M116","borough":"Manhattan","stops":42,"removed":10,"spacingBefore":723,"spacingAfter":954,"riders":4400.0,"minPerTrip":0.9,"riderHoursSaved":51.0,"walkHours2x":73.8,"net":-22.8,"netQuiet":14.1,"breakevenUse":0.69,"breakevenCost":15.9,"busHoursSaved":3.7},{"route":"B14","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":89,"removed":35,"spacingBefore":631,"spacingAfter":1056,"riders":1820.0,"minPerTrip":3.2,"riderHoursSaved":37.4,"walkHours2x":49.2,"net":-11.8,"netQuiet":12.8,"breakevenUse":0.76,"breakevenCost":14.5,"busHoursSaved":8.9},{"route":"B74","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":27,"removed":9,"spacingBefore":638,"spacingAfter":976,"riders":2180.0,"minPerTrip":1.7,"riderHoursSaved":38.1,"walkHours2x":50.9,"net":-12.8,"netQuiet":12.6,"breakevenUse":0.75,"breakevenCost":14.7,"busHoursSaved":3.4},{"route":"B16","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":119,"removed":34,"spacingBefore":703,"spacingAfter":991,"riders":3360.0,"minPerTrip":3.1,"riderHoursSaved":45.0,"walkHours2x":67.6,"net":-22.6,"netQuiet":11.2,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.5,"busHoursSaved":8.8},{"route":"B54","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":65,"removed":17,"spacingBefore":723,"spacingAfter":993,"riders":4150.0,"minPerTrip":1.6,"riderHoursSaved":50.0,"walkHours2x":77.7,"net":-27.7,"netQuiet":11.1,"breakevenUse":0.64,"breakevenCost":17.1,"busHoursSaved":5.1},{"route":"M104","borough":"Manhattan","stops":77,"removed":17,"spacingBefore":727,"spacingAfter":940,"riders":5110.0,"minPerTrip":1.6,"riderHoursSaved":51.6,"walkHours2x":82.4,"net":-30.8,"netQuiet":10.4,"breakevenUse":0.63,"breakevenCost":17.6,"busHoursSaved":4.9},{"route":"B12","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":59,"removed":17,"spacingBefore":799,"spacingAfter":1138,"riders":4710.0,"minPerTrip":1.6,"riderHoursSaved":56.8,"walkHours2x":93.1,"net":-36.3,"netQuiet":10.3,"breakevenUse":0.61,"breakevenCost":18.0,"busHoursSaved":7.8},{"route":"M57","borough":"Manhattan","stops":42,"removed":9,"spacingBefore":741,"spacingAfter":956,"riders":5250.0,"minPerTrip":0.8,"riderHoursSaved":51.3,"walkHours2x":82.1,"net":-30.8,"netQuiet":10.2,"breakevenUse":0.62,"breakevenCost":17.6,"busHoursSaved":2.3},{"route":"B20","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":112,"removed":33,"spacingBefore":704,"spacingAfter":1006,"riders":2790.0,"minPerTrip":3.0,"riderHoursSaved":38.4,"walkHours2x":56.9,"net":-18.5,"netQuiet":9.9,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.3,"busHoursSaved":9.5},{"route":"M8","borough":"Manhattan","stops":42,"removed":16,"spacingBefore":550,"spacingAfter":917,"riders":1030.0,"minPerTrip":1.5,"riderHoursSaved":24.1,"walkHours2x":28.3,"net":-4.2,"netQuiet":9.9,"breakevenUse":0.85,"breakevenCost":12.9,"busHoursSaved":2.8},{"route":"B61","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":82,"removed":20,"spacingBefore":775,"spacingAfter":1033,"riders":5380.0,"minPerTrip":1.8,"riderHoursSaved":56.2,"walkHours2x":93.2,"net":-36.9,"netQuiet":9.7,"breakevenUse":0.6,"breakevenCost":18.2,"busHoursSaved":5.9},{"route":"B64","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":100,"removed":27,"spacingBefore":713,"spacingAfter":986,"riders":3400.0,"minPerTrip":2.5,"riderHoursSaved":42.4,"walkHours2x":66.3,"net":-23.8,"netQuiet":9.3,"breakevenUse":0.64,"breakevenCost":17.2,"busHoursSaved":5.9},{"route":"B48","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":92,"removed":30,"spacingBefore":701,"spacingAfter":1051,"riders":1970.0,"minPerTrip":2.8,"riderHoursSaved":30.2,"walkHours2x":44.9,"net":-14.7,"netQuiet":7.8,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.3,"busHoursSaved":5.9},{"route":"B2","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":42,"removed":13,"spacingBefore":680,"spacingAfter":1012,"riders":1450.0,"minPerTrip":1.2,"riderHoursSaved":22.5,"walkHours2x":30.5,"net":-7.9,"netQuiet":7.3,"breakevenUse":0.74,"breakevenCost":14.9,"busHoursSaved":2.5},{"route":"B100","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":59,"removed":12,"spacingBefore":803,"spacingAfter":1019,"riders":3500.0,"minPerTrip":1.1,"riderHoursSaved":29.4,"walkHours2x":46.7,"net":-17.3,"netQuiet":6.1,"breakevenUse":0.63,"breakevenCost":17.5,"busHoursSaved":4.3},{"route":"B7","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":97,"removed":28,"spacingBefore":754,"spacingAfter":1069,"riders":2550.0,"minPerTrip":2.6,"riderHoursSaved":32.1,"walkHours2x":52.1,"net":-20.0,"netQuiet":6.0,"breakevenUse":0.62,"breakevenCost":17.9,"busHoursSaved":6.0},{"route":"S76","borough":"Staten Island","stops":142,"removed":41,"spacingBefore":694,"spacingAfter":983,"riders":1530.0,"minPerTrip":3.7,"riderHoursSaved":20.7,"walkHours2x":30.7,"net":-9.9,"netQuiet":5.4,"breakevenUse":0.68,"breakevenCost":16.3,"busHoursSaved":8.9},{"route":"B69","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":90,"removed":22,"spacingBefore":747,"spacingAfter":995,"riders":2580.0,"minPerTrip":2.0,"riderHoursSaved":27.9,"walkHours2x":45.3,"net":-17.4,"netQuiet":5.3,"breakevenUse":0.62,"breakevenCost":17.9,"busHoursSaved":3.6},{"route":"M55","borough":"Manhattan","stops":67,"removed":16,"spacingBefore":709,"spacingAfter":942,"riders":1430.0,"minPerTrip":1.5,"riderHoursSaved":15.9,"walkHours2x":23.3,"net":-7.4,"netQuiet":4.2,"breakevenUse":0.68,"breakevenCost":16.1,"busHoursSaved":2.9},{"route":"B31","borough":"Brooklyn","stops":42,"removed":11,"spacingBefore":744,"spacingAfter":1026,"riders":1930.0,"minPerTrip":1.0,"riderHoursSaved":22.9,"walkHours2x":37.3,"net":-14.5,"netQuiet":4.2,"breakevenUse":0.61,"breakevenCost":18.0,"busHoursSaved":2.3},{"route":"M22","borough":"Manhattan","stops":43,"removed":10,"spacingBefore":723,"spacingAfter":956,"riders":1370.0,"minPerTrip":0.9,"riderHoursSaved":15.0,"walkHours2x":22.4,"net":-7.4,"netQuiet":3.8,"breakevenUse":0.67,"breakevenCost":16.5,"busHoursSaved":1.8},{"route":"S42","borough":"Staten Island","stops":43,"removed":12,"spacingBefore":742,"spacingAfter":1044,"riders":250.0,"minPerTrip":1.2,"riderHoursSaved":3.5,"walkHours2x":5.0,"net":-1.5,"netQuiet":1.0,"breakevenUse":0.7,"breakevenCost":15.8,"busHoursSaved":1.1}]},"check":[{"case":"Bronx redesign, Jun 2022","routes":44,"spacingOld":882,"spacingNew":1092,"stopsPerMileCut":1.15,"observedPct":2.5,"predictedRegressionPct":7.4,"predictedMtaPct":4.7,"impliedCost":10.9},{"case":"Queens redesign, Jun-Aug 2025","routes":76,"spacingOld":950,"spacingNew":1300,"stopsPerMileCut":1.5,"observedPct":1.4,"predictedRegressionPct":12.4,"predictedMtaPct":7.6,"impliedCost":3.8}],"strips":[{"route":"M4","direction":"0","to":"Fort Washington Av / Cabrini Blvd","stops":79,"closed":25,"closedMedianGapFt":495,"closedMaxGapFt":660,"window":{"start":45,"stops":[{"name":"Broadway / La Salle St","ft":30828,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / Tiemann Pl","ft":31227,"closed":false,"subway":true},{"name":"Broadway / W 131 St","ft":32225,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 133 St","ft":32720,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 135 St","ft":33522,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 137 St","ft":33853,"closed":false,"subway":true},{"name":"Broadway / W 139 St","ft":34507,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 141 St","ft":35034,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 143 St","ft":35546,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 145 St","ft":36162,"closed":false,"subway":true},{"name":"Broadway / W 147 St","ft":36631,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 149 St","ft":37151,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 151 St","ft":37670,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 153 St","ft":38205,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 155 St","ft":38743,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Broadway / W 157 St","ft":39270,"closed":false,"subway":true},{"name":"Broadway / W 159 St","ft":39794,"closed":true,"subway":false}],"closed":8},"from":"Madison Av / E 32 St"},{"route":"B3","direction":"0","to":"Avenue U / E 71 St","stops":45,"closed":17,"closedMedianGapFt":410,"closedMaxGapFt":622,"window":{"start":18,"stops":[{"name":"Avenue U / E 18 St","ft":12751,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Ocean Av","ft":13456,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 23 St","ft":14154,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Bedford Av","ft":14689,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 28 St","ft":15468,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Nostrand Av","ft":15875,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Brown St","ft":16546,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Ford St","ft":17055,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Bragg St","ft":17447,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Gerritsen Av","ft":17841,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Burnett St","ft":18542,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 33 St","ft":19729,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 35 St","ft":20376,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 37 St","ft":20786,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / E 38 St","ft":21173,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Coleman St","ft":21825,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Avenue U / Hendrickson St","ft":22229,"closed":true,"subway":false}],"closed":9},"from":"25 Av / Harway Av"},{"route":"M11","direction":"0","to":"Riverbank State Park Rdwy / Riverbank State Park","stops":60,"closed":19,"closedMedianGapFt":518,"closedMaxGapFt":640,"window":{"start":15,"stops":[{"name":"10 Av / W 47 St","ft":11159,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"10 Av / W 49 St","ft":11679,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"10 Av / W 53 St","ft":12571,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"10 Av / W 55 St","ft":13235,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"10 Av / W 57 St","ft":13615,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 59 St","ft":14324,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 61 St","ft":14705,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 65 St","ft":15868,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 67 St","ft":16410,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 69 St","ft":16939,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 72 St","ft":17776,"closed":false,"subway":true},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 75 St","ft":18583,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 77 St","ft":19080,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 79 St","ft":19591,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 81 St","ft":20175,"closed":true,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 83 St","ft":20702,"closed":false,"subway":false},{"name":"Amsterdam Av / W 86 St","ft":21533,"closed":true,"subway":false}],"closed":7},"from":"Bethune St / Greenwich St"}]}