Research · Proposal · Updated Oct 5, 2026

Where would bus lanes save riders the most time? Lanes on 12 slow streets would save riders about 720 hours a weekday.

Lanes on the 12 streets where buses lose the most time, and have little or no lane, would save riders about 720 hours each weekday (440 to 1,070), worth $3.5 million a year. Flatbush Av and Broadway lead, close enough to call a tie. A half-hour ride would get about a minute shorter. This is an estimate of what lanes could do, built on the gain past lanes gave, not a forecast for any one street.

How we ranked the streets

For each street, we take the time buses spend each weekday on its blocks without a lane, cut it by 3.2% (the time a 3.3% speed gain saves, the average for new lanes in 2023–25), and multiply by 14, the riders aboard a typical bus. On Flatbush Av, buses spend about 269 hours a weekday on blocks with no lane: 269 × 3.2% ≈ 8.6 bus-hours, × 14 riders ≈ 120 rider-hours. The 12 streets are the ones, of 237 we measured, where buses lose the most time against the street’s own fastest hour and less than half the route-miles have a lane.

Where a lane would save the most

Rider-hours saved each weekday if the blocks of each street without a lane got one, at the typical gain of 3.3%. Flatbush Av and Broadway save the most in all, close enough to call a tie. Per mile of new lane, Madison Av is far ahead: 17 routes share its blocks.

Bus lanes on Flatbush Av and Broadway would save the most time

Rider-hours saved each weekday by a lane on the blocks that lack one, 12 slow New York City streets, 7 am to 7 pm, 2026

    Source: MTA bus segment speeds; MTA bus ridership by route; NYC DOT bus lanes

    Under each street: the share of its route-miles already on a lane, and the miles of street that would need one. Weekdays, 7 am to 7 pm. Streets within a fifth of the leader’s hours count as tied. The 2% to 5% range moves every street up or down together, so it can’t change the order; streets close together, like the top two, could swap if their own gains differ.

    Different versions of the proposal

    The fewer the streets, the more each mile of lane gives back; the more streets, the bigger the total. How well the lanes work matters as much as how many there are.

    If the new lanes speed up buses by
    VersionLane-milesRider-hours a weekdayRider-hours a year Riders’ time a yearBus service a yearPer lane-mile

    The gap opens with the lane

    Buses ran 3.3% faster on 53 stretches that got a new lane from 2023 to 2025 than on similar stretches without one, over the same months (95% interval 1.9% to 4.7%). Before the lanes opened, the two groups moved together; the gap opens the month the lane does and holds on average over the year, though single months late in the year are less sure. Dropping any one corridor leaves the answer between 2.7% and 3.7%, though single streets range from 1.4% (East Gun Hill Rd) to 8.3% (East 96 St). It is the same kind of test as on the congestion pricing evaluation: compare what changed with what didn’t, over the same months.

    New York buses sped up as soon as new bus lanes opened

    Weekday bus speed, 53 stretches given a lane in 2023–25 minus similar stretches without, months from opening, %, with likely ranges (95%)

    Source: MTA bus segment speeds; NYC DOT bus lanes

    Bus speed on stretches that got a new lane, minus matched stretches with no lane, by month from the lane’s opening. Each month is measured against the six months before opening; the opening month itself is left out. Weekdays, 6 am to 8 pm; 53 stretches on 23 routes.

    Where this works and where it doesn’t

    The biggest doubt is that every street gets the same gain; any one street could save from 0.4 to 2.5 times as much (1.4% or 8.3% against 3.3%). What the model leaves out cuts both ways: it misses weekend riders, but also what a lane costs drivers and deliveries.

    • One gain for every street (either way)Single new lanes have given from 1.4% (East Gun Hill Rd) to 8.3% (East 96 St). A street that gains less saves less, and streets close in the ranking could swap.
    • Few Brooklyn lanes, no busways (either way)The 3.3% comes mostly from offset lanes in Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx. Six of the 12 streets are in Brooklyn, and a busway could give more.
    • A package, not paint (would shrink it without the rest)New lanes came with cameras, signal changes and curb rules. Paint alone would likely give less.
    • Riders aboard a bus (either way, by up to 30%)We use 14, a citywide figure; across MTA agencies and years it runs from 10 to 18.
    • What we don’t count (either way)Weekends and riders drawn by faster trips would add to the saving. Lost parking and loading space, slower cars and longer walks would take from it.

    What it means

    • What the data showIf they work as past lanes did, lanes on these 12 streets would save riders about 720 hours a weekday. Flatbush Av (6.1 miles of street to add, each way, 9% on a lane now) and Broadway (8.3 miles, 32% on a lane) save the most in all. Madison Av saves the most per mile, since 17 routes share it, and needs only 4.4 miles, one way.
    • What follows, if it holdsWith only a few miles to paint, Madison Av gives the most back; for the biggest total, Flatbush Av and Broadway. NYC DOT decides on all 12. We haven’t measured what each lane would take from parking, loading or traffic, or what people on each street want, and those can decide whether a lane gets built.

    How this works

    For each street, we take the time buses spend on it each weekday, keep the part on blocks with no bus lane, and cut it by the speed gain new lanes have delivered. Then we turn bus-hours into riders’ hours and dollars.

    • The streetsThe MTA’s bus speeds between timepoint stops, weekdays from 7 am to 7 pm, March to August 2026. A stretch counts for a street when both its stops are on that street. The 12 are the streets losing the most bus time, against each stretch’s fastest hour, with under half their route-miles on a lane.
    • Bus time without a laneFor each stretch: miles ÷ daytime mph × buses a weekday gives bus-hours, times the share of its path not within 15 m of a DOT bus lane. This assumes a bus spends the same time on each block of a stretch.
    • The savingA 3.3% gain in speed cuts travel time by 3.2%. On these 12 streets buses now lose 45% of their time against the street’s fastest hour; the lanes would win back about 6% of that lost time. Some delay is boarding, which no lane fixes.
    • Riders and dollarsBus-hours × 14 riders aboard a bus (National Transit Database, passenger-miles over bus-miles; 10 to 18 across MTA agencies and years) × 250 weekdays × $19.60 an hour, USDOT’s value of time for local trips. Bus-hours × $250 to $290, the MTA’s cost to run a bus for an hour.
    • Lane-milesRoute-miles overstate it: on Madison Av 17 routes share the same blocks. We merge the routes’ paths in each direction, cut out blocks that already have a lane, and measure what’s left. A two-way street needs a lane each way.
    • How sure we areWe grade each answer high, medium or low. High: the range is narrow and every check agrees. Medium: the answer holds, but its size depends on a choice we made, or a check disagrees. Low: the answer rests mainly on an assumption we can’t test.

    The street table’s riders are boardings on every route that touches a street, not riders on that street, so they can’t replace the 14 riders aboard. Bus speeds on these streets are averages over six months. The caveats that matter most are under Where this works and where it doesn’t.

    The arithmetic, for the 12 streets

      What to watch next

      Two things would tighten this ranking: a street-by-street check of what the method would have predicted for the lanes opened in 2023–25, against what they gave, and rider counts by street in place of the citywide 14. To try a lane of your own, use Draw a bus lane. Every number here is in bus-lanes-proposal.json, so you can check our work.