Research · Evaluation · Updated Oct 5, 2026

Did congestion pricing speed up buses? Congestion pricing sped up buses in Manhattan’s core by 3.5%.

In 2025, the toll’s first year (it began January 5), buses ran 2.5% faster inside Manhattan’s congestion zone than in 2024, while the same routes slowed 1% outside it. That gap of 3.5% (range 2.7% to 4.3%) takes about a minute off a 30-minute ride. Part of it is likely recovery from a weak 2024, which would shrink it. In 2026 the gap is 2.4%.

Confidence: medium. The gain is clear, but its size depends on the method, and the two checks of 2024, the year before the toll, disagree: route by route it shows about zero (−0.5%), stop to stop a loss (−1.9%, 95% interval −2.8 to −1.0). Stop to stop, 2025 gives +2.8%.

Where the toll applies

Drivers pay to enter Manhattan below 60 St (60 St included). Many bus routes cross that line, which gives this study its test: the same route, inside the zone and outside it.

Map of Manhattan from the Battery to 110 St, with its streets. The congestion zone, shaded blue, covers everything south of 60 St except the FDR Drive and the West Side Highway. Dots mark the tolled ways in: the Lincoln, Holland, Brooklyn-Battery and Queens-Midtown tunnels, and the Queensboro, Williamsburg, Manhattan and Brooklyn bridges.
The toll applies below 60 St, minus the FDR Drive and West Side Highway. Dots mark the tolled bridges and tunnels. Source: MTA Central Business District Geofence, with its narrow notch at the Brooklyn Bridge ramps smoothed over; streets, parks and land from NYC Planning, NYC Parks and the U.S. Census Bureau.

Faster inside the zone, slower outside it

Average weekday speed, 6 am to 8 pm, of the bus routes that run both inside the zone and outside it (mostly express buses), before and after pricing. The dashed line shows where buses in the zone would have ended up had they changed like the outside.

Congestion pricing sped up buses in Manhattan’s core by 3.5%

Weekday bus speed, same routes inside and outside the toll zone (Manhattan below 60 St), 2024 to 2026, mph, with likely ranges (95%)

First year of pricing

2025 against 2024

2026 so far

January–August 2026 against the same months of 2024

Source: MTA bus speeds

Buses kept most of the gain; taxis and Ubers didn’t. In 2026 buses in the zone are still about 2.4% faster than the same routes outside it. Taxi and Uber trips inside the zone, against trips above 60 St, ran about 2% faster in 2025 and are back level so far in 2026 (−1%, and the 95% interval includes zero). Those two figures are ours, from TLC trip records, not from this page’s data file.

No gain the year before the toll

If something other than the toll had sped up buses in the zone, it would likely have shown up in 2024 too. It didn’t: that year, buses in the zone did slightly worse than the same routes outside (−0.5%).

Buses in Manhattan’s core gained only under congestion pricing

Weekday bus speed change inside the toll zone (Manhattan below 60 St) minus outside, same routes, 2023 to 2026, %, with likely ranges (95%)

    Source: MTA bus speeds

    Difference between the change inside the zone and the change outside, with likely ranges (95%). The bar for 2024 is the test: a year with no toll should show close to zero, and it shows −0.5%.

    Which streets got faster

    Madison Av, 8 Av and the 42 St and 23 St crosstowns gained about 6% in 2025 and were still ahead in 2026. 3 Av, E 23 St and 6 Av gained 3.5% to 5% (6 Av’s interval includes zero), then gave most of it back. Lexington Av was already losing ground in 2024, before the toll, and kept falling. Single streets are rough: several moved by 4 to 5 points in 2024, with no toll (Madison Av −4.5%, 8 Av −4.3%, W 42 St +4.8%).

    Buses clearly sped up on 9 of 16 streets in Manhattan’s congestion pricing zone in 2025

    Weekday bus speed by street in the toll zone (Manhattan below 60 St) minus same routes outside, 2025 vs 2024, %, with likely ranges (95%); Jan–Aug 2026 as numbers

      Source: MTA bus segment speeds

      Change in bus speed on each street inside the zone, minus the change on the same routes outside it. The dots are 2025, the whole year, against 2024. A street is clearly faster when its whole likely range (95%) sits above zero, clearly slower when it sits below, and unclear when it crosses zero. The last column is 2026 so far, January to August, against the same months of 2024; it covers different months, so it isn’t drawn, and on the narrowest phones it moves into each street’s detail. Streets with at least two measured stretches and 5,000 bus-miles in 2024. Hudson St and Pearl St are left out: their buses had an unusual 2024, so their numbers say little about pricing.

      What could change this answer

      Two of these would shrink the 3.5%: a recovery from a weak 2024, and a second method that gives +2.8%. The others could move it either way.

      • A recovery from 2024 (would shrink it)On the stop-to-stop measure, streets fully inside the zone fell behind in 2024 (−1.9%, 95% interval −2.8 to −1.0). If 2025 partly made up that loss, pricing’s own share is smaller than 3.5%. The data can’t say by how much.
      • Another fair method gives less (would shrink it)Stop-to-stop speeds, which weight routes differently, give +2.8% for 2025 (1.8 to 3.7) and +1.9% for 2026 (0.7 to 3.0).
      • Traffic outside the zone (either way)Each route is compared with its own stretch outside the zone. If pricing pushed traffic onto those streets and slowed them, the gap overstates the gain; if it sped them up, the gap understates it.
      • Mostly express buses (either way)Most routes in the main comparison are express buses; their Manhattan stretch is the part in the zone. Routes that stay inside the zone could have gained more or less.
      • Chance (either way)The range, 2.7% to 4.3%, covers chance swings from route to route. It doesn’t cover the biases above.

      What it means

      • What the data showIn its first year, congestion pricing took about a minute off a 30-minute bus ride in Manhattan below 60 St. In 2026 the gain is smaller, 2.4%. The same routes slowed outside the zone, so riders there got nothing from it. Speed is all we measured: these numbers say nothing about the toll’s cost to drivers or where its money goes.
      • What follows, if it holds2026 sits lower: on the same months and stretches, the gap is 1.1 points smaller than in 2025 (95% interval −1.8 to −0.4). If it keeps narrowing, the toll alone won’t hold buses at 2025 speeds. Taxis and Ubers have already lost their gain.
      • Our viewIf traffic returns, bus lanes can hold the gain: new lanes made buses 3.3% faster (our bus lane study).

      How this works

      Each bus route is compared with itself. The MTA splits every route’s miles and hours into the part inside the zone (Manhattan below 60 St) and the part outside. Whatever changed for the whole route, such as new buses, schedules or weather, shows up on both sides and cancels out.

      • Route by routeFor each route and month, the change in speed inside the zone against the same month a year before, minus the same change outside. Averaged over 99 routes, weighted by miles in the zone. Weekdays, 6 am to 8 pm. The 95% intervals come from resampling routes.
      • The speeds in the chartMiles over hours for each route and month, averaged with the same weights, so their changes match the headline numbers.
      • Street by streetThe MTA’s bus speeds between timepoint stops. A stretch counts for a street when both its stops are on that street and inside the zone. Each stretch is compared with its own route outside the zone.
      • The test yearThe same comparison for 2024 against 2023, before the toll. It should show nothing, and it shows −0.5%.
      • How sure we areWe grade each answer high, medium or low. High: the range is narrow and every check agrees. Medium: the answer holds, but its size depends on a choice we made, or a check disagrees. Low: the answer rests mainly on an assumption we can’t test.

      Speed includes time at stops and lights. The caveats that matter most are under What could change this answer.

      What to watch next

      The 2026 gap is smaller than 2025’s, and the MTA’s September figures are next. If the gap falls toward zero, buses are losing what pricing gave them; if it holds near 2.4%, the gain is lasting. Every bus number on this page is in congestion-pricing.json, so you can check our work; the taxi and Uber figures come from TLC trip records.