Research · Evaluation · Updated Oct 7, 2026

Did free buses bring more riders? Five free bus routes drew 30% more riders, mostly people already riding.

For a year from September 2023, one bus route in each borough ran free. Weekday riders on them rose 30%, against 6% on all buses, but only 12% were new to the route. Nearby routes lost about 5% of their paying riders (range 0.4% to 8.7%), an upper bound, since fare evasion there rose faster than elsewhere. The free routes didn’t speed up; they slowed 1.4%. It cost $16.5 million, about $4 an extra trip.

The +30% and 12% are the MTA’s counts and survey, with no range; our own figures have one. Confidence: high that riders rose, since the gain is five times the citywide one; medium on the nearby loss and the slowdown, since fare evasion and other changes on those routes could explain part of each.

What the pilot was for

The 2023 state budget told the MTA to make one bus route in each borough free for six to twelve months. The state capped the cost at $15 million. The MTA chose the Bx18A/B, B60, M116, Q4 and S46/S96.

The aims, as the MTA and the city’s budget office describe them

  1. Help riders who need it most. Routes were picked for “equity for low income and disadvantaged communities” (MTA).
  2. Reach jobs and shops. And for “access to employment and commercial area(s)” (MTA).
  3. Keep the test clean. Routes with room on board, little overlap with other buses, and known fare evasion levels (MTA).
  4. Measure what changes. The MTA reported riders, service delivered, speed, on-time journeys, time at stops, cost by route, frequency and assaults on bus operators. A 2025 bill to expand the pilot (S4421, not passed) lists the same measures.

Neither the MTA nor the law set a target, such as a number of new riders. We quote the MTA’s 1-year evaluation (June 2025) and the city’s Independent Budget Office (June 2026), not the budget law itself.

More riders, slower buses, over budget

Free fares did what free fares usually do: more trips, mostly from people already riding. Service got a little worse, assaults on drivers fell, and the bill came in above the cap. The MTA did not report on rider satisfaction.

Aim by aim

    RouteRiders beforeWeekdaysWeekendsCostPer extra tripDriver assaultsSpeed

    Riders: weekday riders, September 2022–May 2023, and the change in the same months of the pilot, from the MTA’s passenger counters. Cost: the MTA’s full cost by route. Per extra trip: that cost over the MTA’s extra riders a day times the days of the pilot (our sum, rough). Driver assaults: verbal and physical, a year before and during. Speed: ours, against similar routes that kept fares.

    Nearby routes lost paying riders; some came back

    Paid riders fell near New York’s fare-free buses; some came back

    Weekday paid riders, 19 routes beside the five free routes minus similar routes farther away, Oct 2021–May 2025, %, with likely ranges (95%)

    Source: MTA bus hourly ridership

    Bus speeds near New York’s fare-free routes barely changed

    Weekday bus speed, 19 routes beside the five free routes minus similar routes farther away, Oct 2021–May 2025, %, with likely ranges (95%)

    Source: MTA bus speeds

    RouteNext toPaid riders beforePaid ridersSpeed

    The 19 routes with at least a fifth of their path within 400 m of a free route. Each is compared with up to five routes in its borough that run nowhere near a free route and were closest to it in speed and paid riders. Paid riders before: a weekday, October 2022–August 2023. Changes: October 2023–August 2024 against a year before, minus the change on the comparison routes.

    Where the new trips came from

      Free routes didn’t get faster

      Riders no longer stopped to pay, but more of them got on. Against similar routes in the same boroughs that kept fares, the free routes slowed by 1.4% (range 0.3% to 2.3%), about half of it in the summer of 2024. That gap didn’t close when fares came back, so we can’t pin it all on free fares. What the data do rule out is a speed-up.

      New York’s five fare-free bus routes got slower, not faster

      Weekday bus speed, five fare-free routes and similar routes with fares, 2022–23 vs 2023–24, mph; below, monthly gap, %; likely ranges (95%)

      Each month against October 2022–August 2023. Average of the five routes.

      Source: MTA bus speeds

      What could change this answer

      Fare evasion would shrink the loss on nearby routes, and other changes on the free routes would shrink the share of the slowdown that free fares caused. The rest could move the answer either way.

      • Fare taps miss riders who don’t pay (would shrink the nearby loss)
      • Something else slowed the free routes (would shrink the slowdown)The gap didn’t close when fares came back, so something else about those routes may have changed in 2024.
      • Few routes (either way)Five free routes and 19 nearby routes are small samples, so the ranges are rough.
      • The MTA’s figures have no range (either way)The rider counts, survey and costs are the MTA’s. We can’t say how far chance moves them, and the survey shares are read off the MTA’s charts.

      What it means

      • What the data show
      • What follows, if it holdsDrawing on the pilot, the city’s budget office assumed citywide free buses would raise riders 25%, at just over $1.1 billion a year from 2027 (June 2026). If the pilot’s pattern holds, most of that money would go to people already riding, and buses would not get faster. But the pilot routes were picked for room on board and little overlap with other buses, so a citywide program could differ, in either direction.
      • Our viewOn this evidence, free fares are a way to cut what riders pay, not a way to speed up buses.

      How this works

      The riders on the free routes, the survey, the costs and the service figures are the MTA’s. The free routes’ own fare taps fell to almost nothing while they were free, so public data can’t count their riders in that year. Our own work covers what public data can show: paid riders and speed on nearby routes, and speed on the free routes.

      • The yearsOctober to August, to skip September 2023, when the pilot began part-way through (September 24). Before: October 2022–August 2023. Fare-free: October 2023–August 2024. After: October 2024–May 2025, stopping before the Bronx and Queens redesigns of late June 2025.
      • Comparison routesLocal or limited routes in the same borough that run nowhere near a free route (under 5% of their path within 400 m) and not in Manhattan’s congestion zone, picked as the five closest in speed and paid riders before the pilot.
      • The effectFor each route, the change against the same months a year before, minus the average change on its comparison routes. Free routes count equally; nearby routes are weighted by their paid riders. The 95% intervals come from resampling routes, and each route’s comparison routes, 2,000 times.
      • Nearby routesAt least a fifth of the path within 400 m of a free route, using each route’s timepoint stops in June 2023.
      • Cost per extra tripThe MTA’s $16.5 million full cost over the MTA’s extra riders a day (weekdays and weekends, school months and summer) times the 343 days of the pilot.
      • What we leave outWeekends (in our own numbers); express and Select Bus Service routes; September of every year; the Bx18’s speeds before October 2022, when its numbers jump.
      • How sure we areWe grade each answer high, medium or low. High: the range is narrow and every check agrees. Medium: the answer holds, but its size depends on a choice we made, or a check disagrees. Low: the answer rests mainly on an assumption we can’t test.

      The caveats that matter most are under What could change this answer.

      What to watch next

      A 2025 bill to expand the pilot (S4421) did not pass. If New York tries free buses again, watch the measures on this page: riders new to the route, not just trips; speed against routes that kept fares; and paid riders on routes nearby. Every number here is in fare-free-pilot.json, so you can check our work.