Research · Proposal · Updated Oct 5, 2026

Should New York space its bus stops further apart? Closing 1,000 quiet bus stops would save riders about 600 hours a day, at best.

Close the stops within 750 ft of the next one on 40 tightly spaced routes in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Staten Island, and riders save about 600 hours a day, even counting each minute of extra walking twice. That holds only if the stops closed carry half their route’s average riders; at average use, riders lose time. Spacing every route to a quarter mile would cost riders about 36,000 hours a day more than it saves.

Past redesigns saved 4 to 11 seconds a stop

The MTA has done this twice. The Bronx redesign (June 2022) and the Queens redesign (June and August 2025) both spread stops further apart. Buses got faster, but by far less than the model expected. That is why this page is cautious.

Bronx and Queens bus redesigns sped buses less than expected

Local bus speed gain after New York’s Bronx (2022) and Queens (2025) redesigns, net of other boroughs, against the gain expected, %

Source: MTA bus route speeds; Bronx and Queens bus network redesign plans

At what redesigns achieved, wider spacing mostly costs riders time

Net rider-hours each weekday, citywide: time saved on board minus extra walking. Three spacing rules, four stop costs. Real redesigns achieved 4 seconds a stop in Queens and 11 in the Bronx. At 11 seconds, every rule loses riders time if the stops closed are as busy as average. If they are half as busy, the 750 ft rule gains about 450 rider-hours a day, while 1,000 ft (about −2,350) and a quarter mile (about −10,050) still lose.

Quarter-mile bus stop spacing would cost New York riders time

Net rider-hours on a 2026 weekday, New York buses except express: time saved on board minus walking counted twice, by stop cost, average stop use

Walking counts
Stops closed are

Source: MTA bus GTFS schedules; MTA bus ridership by route; MTA bus segment speeds

750 ft spacing pays off on 40 tightly spaced routes

The 750 ft rule on the routes where it still pays at 11 seconds a stop. These have the tightest stops, so each rider passes more of the ones that close. Ranked by net rider-hours a day if the stops closed carry half their route’s average riders. The last column says how busy they can be before the route stops gaining.

RouteBoroughStops closedGap, ft Min off a full tripNet rider-hours a dayPays while closed stops carry under

The M4, stop by stop

750 ft bus stop spacing would close 8 of these 17 M4 stops in Manhattan

One stretch of the M4 in Manhattan, Broadway from La Salle St to W 159 St, drawn to scale, weekday schedule of September 16, 2026

Source: MTA bus GTFS schedules

What could change this answer

Two assumptions decide whether the plan saves time or costs it: how busy the closed stops are, and how many seconds a stop costs. The rest would mostly shrink the saving.

  • How busy the closed stops are (could flip it)There is no public count of riders at each stop, so the model treats every stop on a route alike and assumes the ones closed carry half the average. At average use, the plan costs riders about 1,240 hours a day.
  • What a stop costs (could flip it)We use 11 s, what the Bronx redesign gave. The Queens redesign gave 4 s; at that cost no route on the list gains. The MTA’s 20 s or our 31 s would raise the saving.
  • Who walks further (would shrink it)For older riders and people with disabilities an extra block can be the whole trip. Rider-hours count every minute alike, so they leave that cost out, and our rules don’t yet protect stops by hospitals, senior centres and schools.
  • Walks on a real street (would shrink it)We measure walking along the route, not on a street map, and ignore hills, crossings and weather.
  • Waiting (either way)We don’t model it. A longer wait in the cold or the dark is a cost; the bus-hours saved could run more buses and shorten waits.

What it means

  • What the data showClosing stops within 750 ft of the next on 40 routes would save riders about 600 hours a day, but only if the stops closed are the quiet ones and each costs a bus about 11 s, as in the Bronx. Spacing every route to a quarter mile would cost riders time.
  • What follows, if it holdsThe case for closing stops is route by route and stop by stop, not a citywide spacing rule. The people who walk further, often older riders and people with disabilities, bear the cost; a plan would need to keep stops by hospitals, senior centres and schools, which would cut the saving.

How this works

For every local, limited and Select Bus Service route, we took its usual weekday stop list and measured the distance between stops along the route. Then we closed stops under each rule, and weighed the time saved by riders on board against the extra walk for riders who used the closed stops.

  • The rulesFind the closest pair of stops under the minimum spacing (750, 1,000 or 1,320 ft) and close whichever one leaves the more even gaps. Repeat until no pair is too close. Never closed: the first and last stop, any stop within 100 m of a subway station, and any stop where two or more other routes cross. No closure may leave a gap over twice the minimum.
  • What a stop costsRegressing the MTA’s bus times between timepoints on the number of stops between them gives 30.8 s a stop (95% interval 23.7 to 37.4). The MTA plans on about 20 s. But the speed gains the Bronx and Queens redesigns actually delivered match only 11 s and 4 s a stop. We use 11 s as the central case.
  • Riders on boardEach route’s weekday boardings (March–August 2026), spread evenly over its stops. Riders passing a stop = boardings × an average trip of 2 miles ÷ route length.
  • WalkingPeople who used a closed stop walk to the nearest one left, at 3 mph. They are spread evenly along the street, so the average extra walk is about half the new gap. Each minute of walking counts as two minutes on the bus, the usual planning weight.
  • The targeted listRoutes where the 750 ft rule still saves time at 11 s a stop as long as the stops closed carry under 60% of the route’s average riders, and that lose at least five stops.
  • How sure we areWe grade each answer high, medium or low. High: the range is narrow and every check agrees. Medium: the answer holds, but its size depends on a choice we made, or a check disagrees. Low: the answer rests mainly on an assumption we can’t test.

The redesign check compares boroughs, not single routes, and both redesigns changed more than stops. The caveats that matter most are under What could change this answer.

What to watch next

The MTA counts riders at each stop with its passenger counters; we can’t. Those counts would settle the question this page can’t: whether the stops on our list are quiet enough to close. To try it on one route, use Close a stop. Every number here is in stop-balancing.json, so you can check our work.